Friday, December 14, 2012

Loftis v. Almager, No. 09-16884 (12-11-12) (Adelman, D.J. ED Wisconsin; concurrence by Silverman; dissent by Tashima)
In habeas, does a "no contest" plea with a reference to the state equivalent of an Alford plea (California's West case) require a factual basis to be stated at the change of plea? The opinion, penned by a single judge, holds "no."  The defendant here pled to second degree murder under California law. The defendant sold meth to a minor who overdosed and he failed to get her medical aid. Yet, at the change of plea, the court never stated a factual basis. The defendant however never said he was innocent. The failure to not protest innocence did not constitutionalize the proceeding, and there was no requirement for a factual basis. A reference to West/Alford did not transform the "no contest" plea into an Alford one. Concurring, Silverman joins the judgment, but agrees with the dissent that a factual basis was required. However, he would look to the presentence report to furnish it (a modified approach). Dissenting, Tashima would require a factual basis as the plea proceeding was akin to an Alford plea, which is a claim of innocence. Thus, for him, a factual basis should be required.

The opinion is a rare one in which the writers all offer different approaches, refer to one another by name, and engage in a spirited discussion of positions.

AFPD Carolyn Wiggins of ED California fought the good fight.

3 Comments:

Blogger youjioa rs said...

I have to say your article inspires me to the most, it is so instructive to tell others how to understand that in such a special view.I will share your articles with my friends, i think they will like them just like me. What's more, can you update them more frequently? I am a fan of online games. rs gold , runescape gold

Friday, December 21, 2012 7:09:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The opinion is a rare one in which the writers all offer different approaches, refer to one another by name, and engage in a spirited discussion of positions.swtor gold
tor credits
cheap swtor credits
swtor credits
buy swtor credits
swtor credits for sale

Tuesday, December 25, 2012 5:52:00 PM  
Blogger love thomass said...

Come on! Christmas is just around the corner, as a thanks and reward for subscribers support, diablohome give out free $1 and $5 voucher for all newsletter subscribers and you can use it when diablo goldor any products on our site. Hurry to see more details!


What can I get from Diablohome Newsletter?
1.Free $1 and $5 vouchers.
2. Free Diablo 3 guide and latest update information of the game.
3. Latest promotions on Diablohome site.
More tags :Diablo 3 gold buy diablo 3 gold D3 gold

Wednesday, December 26, 2012 1:48:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home