1. US v. Onuoha, No. 15-50300
(4-20-16)(Gould with Berzon and Steeh, D.J.)
This is a Sell involuntary medication issue. The 9th reverses the district court's order
for involuntary medication to treat defendant's schizophrenia and to restore
him to competency. The 9th found that
the government had an important interest in prosecuting the defendant, who had
made a threat that shut down LAX.
However, under Sell, the defendant has a self-interest in the best
medical course of action. The district
court clearly erred in finding that involuntary medication was in the
defendant's best interests given the effect of anti-psychotic medication under
the circumstances, the course of treatment, and the amount proposed to be
given. The 9th remands to the court for
a full consideration of the best medical interest of the defendant and the
contradictory medical evidence.
The decision is here:
http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/04/20/15-50300.pdf
Congrats to Brianna Mircheff, Deputy FPD, Cal
Central (L.A.).
2. US v. Cruz, No. 10-50115 (4-20-16)(Bybee
with Farris and N. Smith). The 9th affirms
a life sentence for a mid-level drug dealer because he had two prior drug
felonies and such a sentence is mandated by 21 U.S.C. ยง 841. The sentence is mandated even though, under
California's Prop 47, one of the state priors was reclassified as a misdemeanor. The 9th holds that a subsequent change and
reclassification of a state conviction would not impact a federal sentence
properly imposed at the time. The 9th
has previously found that a prior conviction, even subsequently expunged or
dismissed, would not alter a sentence.
If a dismissal didn't cause a resentencing on the recidivist statute, a
reclassification also would not. The 9th
also stated that Congress could have allowed for such reconsideration, or have
changed 841, but it hasn't. The recidivist
statute also serves a purpose to "send a message."
The decision is here:
http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/04/20/10-50029.pdf
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home